Big Brother fans want an all-AFH season and here’s who would appear
Many Big Brother fans have been asking the producers to switch things up. Rather than having a new cast with a returner (like Rachel Reilly) or a celebrity (like Cirie Fields), some viewers would like to see a theme that involves returning players who fit a role.
Some viewers have suggested a season where the first person to get evicted is invited back from every season. A more interesting idea that keeps getting presented is for people who have accomplished something on the show to return.
A season featuring America’s Favorite Houseguests
Each season, someone is named America’s Favorite Houseguest. Could a season featuring all the past AFH winners be fun? Social media certainly loves the idea. It would mean popular players from the past are invited to compete in a new season.
But would fans really be happy with the people returning? Or would it just lead to more complaints about cast construction? Let’s take a look!
Below is a list of the players who have won America’s Favorite Houseguest. Notable entries include Big Brother 24 winner Taylor Hale, two-time winner Jeff Schroeder, and four-time player Janelle Pierzina.
- Keanu Soto (BB27
- Tucker Des Lauriers (BB26)
- Cameron Hardin (BB25)
- Taylor Hale (BB24)
- Tiffany Mitchell (BB23)
- Da’Vonne Rogers (BB22: All-Stars 2)
- Nicole Anthony (BB21)
- Tyler Crispen (BB20)
- Cody Nickson (BB19)
- Victor Arroyo (BB18)
- James Huling (BB17)
- Donny Thompson (BB16)
- Elissa Slater (BB15)
- Frank Eudy (BB14)
- Jeff Schroeder (BB13 and BB11)
- Britney Haynes (BB12)
- Keesha Smith (BB10)
- James Zinkand (BB9)
- Janelle Pierzina (BB7: All-Stars 1)
Big Brother fans ask for an all-AFH season
Among the fan posts about a season only featuring America’s Favorite Houseguests is a twist idea where America would decide the winner. It also suggests giving the AFH from that season the $750,000 prize. It’s bold.
“When they do an AFP season of big brother so that Britney can get her deserved win that Dan deprived her of,” another fan posted.
They were referring to BB14, where Britney Haynes and Dan Gheesling returned as coaches.
Differing fan opinions about who deserves to win could be amplified by former AFHs returning to play again. That could lead to a fascinating season
What do you think? Would you want to watch a season where America’s Favorite Houseguest winners battled it out?
